Poor Managers
We train thousands of managers each year and every now and again we come across the "know all"
I am sure you know the type! Those managers who reckon they do not need any training, that "you can’t teach me anything"
They sit there arms folded, they disrupt the others in the group and are a general nuisance. The very fact that they act in this way tells me they have no understanding of the impact of their actions and behaviour on others and need training.
Anyhow, we came across one of these managers on a recent management development programme.
When my trainer checked in with me at the end of the day here’s what she wrote in her email to me:
We did the Kolb Learning Styles questionnaire…her reaction?
“What’s the point? They’re only words! Arr, this is useless!”
“It says I’m a convergent thinker. So that means I’m not balanced. I’m a misfit. I might as well leave!”
We did the Management Styles Survey…her reaction?
“Pointless! Who says that I can only manage one way? I don’t believe this.”
We did the “square wheels exercise”. Most people get between 10 and 15 answers. Her reaction?
“I only got one answer. This is useless!”
I suggested that her team try some of the games on their table while they waited for other teams to finish. Her reaction?
“I’m not spacial, so I can’t do this!”
I set a five-to-ten minute reading exercise to do overnight, ready for an activity first thing tomorrow. Her reaction?
“You seem to think that we haven’t got anything to do tonight!”
I found this quite amusing. The rest of the group loved the days training but this one individual thought better.
Anyhow, we got feedback from the rest of the group and they were "ashamed" of her. We duly kicked her off the course and the entire programme.
You can lead the horse to water…
Sean Mc









August 21st, 2008 at 11:09 am
[...] Surprised to hear the question, but having always had honest conversations with this manager, she hesitated only slightly before telling him that most of the employees he managed found him to be grumpy and unapproachable. She reiterated that she understood he had been given the unfortunate task of delivering layoff notices to so many people, but that his attitude towards others had been cold and aloof for much longer than the few months before the organisational changes. While anyone would have admitted he was a valuable informational resource and shrewd business person, no one found him personable and many thought he was a poor manager. [...]